Mu'awiyah refuses allegiance to Ali; at Siffin the 90-year-old Ammar ibn Yasir is killed by Mu'awiyah's side - fulfilling "a rebellious group will kill Ammar" - and the battle ends in arbitration.
Mu'awiyah, governor of Syria and Uthman's kinsman, refused to pledge to Ali until Uthman's killers were handed over. The armies met at Siffin on the Euphrates. Ammar ibn Yasir, about ninety and fighting for Ali, was killed. The Prophet ﷺ had said to him while building the mosque, "Woe to Ammar; the rebellious group will kill him; he will be calling them to Paradise and they will be calling him to the Fire" (Sahih al-Bukhari 447; Sahih Muslim 2916). The killer is named in reports as Abu al-Ghadiyah al-Juhani (Musnad Ahmad; ).
When the Syrians were losing, on Amr ibn al-As's advice they raised copies of the Qur'an on their spears calling for Allah's Book to judge. Many in Ali's army forced him to stop and accept arbitration (). The Prophet ﷺ had also said two great groups would fight "with one claim" (Bukhari 6935).
Ammar's death was taken by Companions at the time as proof of which side was in the right.
Disputed Where sources or scholars differ
- Sunni scholars (e.g. al-Nawawi on Muslim 2916) conclude Ali was in the right and Mu'awiyah's side erred, while refraining from cursing Companions. Some later defenders of Mu'awiyah offered other readings; Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza cites this hadith for Ali being in the right. Casualty totals in the sources (tens of thousands) are not reliable.
People
- Ali Caliph
- Mu'awiyah Governor of Syria; refused allegiance
- Ammar ibn Yasir Killed - the sign of the "rebellious group"
- Amr ibn al-As Advised raising the Qur'an
- Abu al-Ghadiyah Reported killer of Ammar