After the Prophet ﷺ
Sunni & Shia: where the paths parted
وَاعْتَصِمُوا بِحَبْلِ اللَّهِ جَمِيعًا وَلَا تَفَرَّقُوا
“Hold firmly to the rope of Allah all together and do not be divided” (3:103)
Sunni and Shia Muslims share the Qur'an, the Prophet ﷺ, the five daily prayers, the fast, zakat and the Hajj. They differ mainly over who should have led the community after the Prophet ﷺ, and over how to judge some of the people and events that followed.
This page puts the two readings side by side, event by event, starting where the divide began. Each column gives the view of mainstream scholarship in that tradition with sources from that tradition. The "Both accept" line shows what the shared sources say. Red markers show where the difference became deeper.
In line with the method used across this site (Qur'an and authentic sources first, no sectarian name-calling), neither column is presented as the "winner". Where the sources disagree, both are shown.
-
1
18 Dhu al-Hijjah 10 AH (March 632 CE)
Ghadir Khumm
●● Different readings
Both accept
On the way back from the Farewell Hajj the Prophet ﷺ stopped at Ghadir Khumm and said: "Whoever I am his mawla, Ali is his mawla" (Jami' al-Tirmidhi 3713, sahih). He also urged people to hold to the Book of Allah and his Ahl al-Bayt (Sahih Muslim 2408).
Why it matters: The meaning of one word, mawla, became the root of two different theories of leadership.
On the timeline →Sunni reading
A strong statement of Ali's rank and of the duty to love and support him. "Mawla" means friend, ally or protector here. Ibn Kathir links it to complaints about Ali from the army returning from Yemen. It was not an appointment as ruler: had it been, the Companions would not have met at the Saqifah as they did.
Shia reading
An explicit public appointment of Ali as the Prophet's successor and guardian (wali) of the believers. Shia exegetes link Qur'an 5:67 ("convey what has been sent down to you") and 5:3 ("today I have perfected your religion") to this day. Celebrated as Eid al-Ghadir.
Qur'an 5:3, 5:67 · (Kitab al-Hujjah) · · al-Amini, al-Ghadir (modern compilation of the chains)
-
2
Thursday before the Prophet's death, Rabi' al-Awwal 11 AH
The pen and paper ("the calamity of Thursday")
●● Different readings
Both accept
In his last illness the Prophet ﷺ asked for writing material to write something after which they would not go astray. Umar said the pain had overcome him and "the Book of Allah is enough for us"; voices rose and the Prophet ﷺ told them to leave. Ibn Abbas called it a calamity (Sahih al-Bukhari 114, 4432).
Why it matters: The same Bukhari report is read as an act of care by one side and an act of defiance by the other.
On the timeline →Sunni reading
Umar acted out of concern for the very sick Prophet ﷺ. The Prophet ﷺ lived several more days and did not insist, but gave other final instructions (Sahih al-Bukhari 4431). Nothing of the religion was left unconveyed (Qur'an 5:3).
Sahih al-Bukhari 114, 4431-4432 · Qur'an 5:3 · (commentary on 114)
Shia reading
The Prophet ﷺ meant to put Ali's succession in writing and was prevented. The incident shows that some Companions were already resisting the Prophet's will.
· Sharaf al-Din, al-Muraja'at (modern)
-
3
Rabi' al-Awwal 11 AH (June 632 CE)
Saqifah: where the divide began
●●● The divide deepened
Both accept
While the family were preparing the burial, the Ansar met at the Saqifah of Banu Sa'idah. Abu Bakr, Umar and Abu Ubaydah joined them and Abu Bakr was pledged caliph. Umar later called it sudden ("falta") (Sahih al-Bukhari 6830). Ali and Banu Hashim were not present, and Ali pledged after six months (Sahih al-Bukhari 4240-4241).
Why it matters: The two views of the Saqifah are the starting point of everything below.
On the timeline →Sunni reading
A valid choice by consultation (shura) at a moment of real danger. Abu Bakr was the most deserving: the Prophet ﷺ had him lead the prayers in his final illness (Sahih al-Bukhari 664) and called him his closest companion (Sahih al-Bukhari 466). Ali's eventual pledge confirms the caliphate.
Shia reading
Ali's divinely appointed right was set aside while he was busy with the Prophet's burial. His delayed pledge shows he did not accept it. In the Shiqshiqiyyah sermon Ali says he "knew his position in relation to it was that of the axis to the mill".
(sermon 3, al-Shiqshiqiyyah) · ·
-
4
11 AH (632 CE)
Fadak and Fatimah's inheritance
●● Different readings
Both accept
Fatimah asked Abu Bakr for her inheritance, including Fadak. He cited "we prophets are not inherited; what we leave is charity". She was angry and did not speak to him until she died six months later (Sahih al-Bukhari 4240-4241).
Why it matters: Fatimah's anger (Bukhari 3714: "whoever angers her angers me") turned a property dispute into a question of faith for Shia Muslims.
On the timeline →Sunni reading
Abu Bakr was bound by the Prophet's words, which Umar later had Ali, al-Abbas, Uthman, al-Zubayr, Abd al-Rahman and Sa'd confirm (Sahih al-Bukhari 3094). The family kept being supported from Fadak's income. When Ali became caliph he did not change this.
-
5
11 AH
Events at Fatimah's house
●●● The divide deepened
Both accept
Al-Tabari (year 11) and Ibn Abi Shaybah report that Umar went to the house where those who had not pledged had gathered and threatened to burn it unless they came out to pledge.
Why it matters: This is one of the most painful points of difference. It is the basis of the Shia criticism of the first caliphs, and Sunni scholars reject that criticism.
On the timeline →Sunni reading
Sunni scholars differ over how strong these reports are, and reject later stories of an assault on Fatimah. They point to later good relations: Ali named sons Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman (also listed in al-Mufid's al-Irshad) and married his daughter Umm Kulthum to Umar (Sahih al-Bukhari 2881).
(year 11) · Sahih al-Bukhari 2881 · (list of Ali's children)
Shia reading
The house was attacked, the door was forced, Fatimah was injured and miscarried her son al-Muhsin, and she died soon after. This is commemorated as Ayyam al-Fatimiyyah. On the Umm Kulthum marriage that Sunni scholars cite, Shia scholars differ: al-Kulayni's al-Kafi records Imam Ja'far al-Sadiq calling it "a marriage taken from us by force", so many accept it happened under pressure, while al-Shaykh al-Mufid rejected the report as unreliable (al-Masa'il al-Sarawiyya).
· · (Kitab al-Nikah, bab tazwij Umm Kulthum) · (question 10)
-
6
11-35 AH (632-656 CE)
Ali under the first three caliphs
● Shared ground
Both accept
Ali did not take up arms. He advised the caliphs, judged cases and stayed in Madinah. Abu Bakr was followed by Umar (13 AH) and Uthman (23 AH). Uthman was chosen by a council of six that included Ali (Sahih al-Bukhari 3700).
Why it matters: Both agree Ali chose unity over conflict. They disagree about what that choice meant.
Sunni reading
Ali's cooperation shows these were legitimate caliphates and that he and the others respected each other. Sunni Muslims rank the four caliphs in the order they ruled.
Shia reading
Ali was patient (sabr) to protect Islam and the unity of the Muslims, not because he gave up his right: "I was patient, though there was a thorn in the eye and a bone in the throat" ().
(sermon 3)
-
7
35 AH (656 CE)
The murder of Uthman
●● Different readings
Both accept
Complaints against Uthman's governors (al-Walid ibn Uqbah, Ibn Abi Sarh, Marwan) grew. Rebels besieged and killed him in Madinah ().
Why it matters: Both agree Ali was innocent of the killing. They judge Uthman's rule very differently.
On the timeline →Sunni reading
Uthman was the third rightly guided caliph and was killed wrongfully. The Prophet ﷺ foretold Paradise for him "with a calamity" (Sahih al-Bukhari 3695). Ali tried to protect him.
Sahih al-Bukhari 3695 · (year 35)
Shia reading
The grievances were real, and Uthman's favouring of Banu Umayyah caused the crisis. Ali tried to mediate between Uthman and the people () and did not take part in the killing.
·
-
8
Jumada 36 AH (December 656 CE)
Ali's caliphate and the Battle of the Camel
●● Different readings
Both accept
Ali was pledged as caliph in Madinah. Talhah, al-Zubayr and Aisha went to Basra demanding revenge for Uthman, and thousands died in the battle near Basra. Talhah and al-Zubayr were killed, and Ali sent Aisha back to Madinah with honour ().
Why it matters: Sunni scholars give all the Companions involved the benefit of good intention. Shia scholars hold the opponents responsible.
On the timeline →Sunni reading
Ali was the rightful fourth caliph. The battle was a tragedy between Companions who each had their reasons, and some of it was sparked by provocateurs. Aisha later regretted going out. All of them are respected.
(year 36) · (year 36)
Shia reading
For the first time the Imam was also the ruler. Talhah and al-Zubayr broke their pledge, and Aisha was wrong to lead an army against him.
·
-
9
Safar 37 AH (July 657 CE)
Siffin
●● Different readings
Both accept
Mu'awiyah refused to pledge allegiance to Ali until Uthman's killers were handed over, and the armies met at Siffin. Ammar ibn Yasir was killed by Mu'awiyah's army. The Prophet ﷺ had foretold that "the rebellious group will kill him" (Sahih al-Bukhari 447).
Why it matters: Both accept the hadith of Ammar. They disagree on how to judge Mu'awiyah personally.
On the timeline →Sunni reading
Ali was in the right and Mu'awiyah's side was the rebellious group (Bukhari 447). Many Sunni scholars call it an error of judgement (ijtihad) by a Companion, and Muslims are told not to curse the Companions (Sahih al-Bukhari 3673).
Shia reading
Mu'awiyah knowingly rebelled against the Imam of his time for worldly power. The hadith of Ammar proves it.
·
-
10
37-38 AH (657-658 CE)
The arbitration and the Khawarij
● Shared ground
Both accept
Pages of the Qur'an were raised on spears and an arbitration was agreed. A group rejected it with the slogan "judgement belongs only to Allah", declared Ali a disbeliever and was defeated at Nahrawan. The Prophet ﷺ had said they would be killed by "the party nearer to the truth" (Sahih Muslim 1064-1066).
Why it matters: Here the two traditions agree. Both reject the Khawarij.
On the timeline →Sunni reading
The Khawarij were the first sect to break away and declare other Muslims disbelievers, and Ali was right to fight them.
Sahih Muslim 1064-1066
Shia reading
The same: the Khawarij were misguided extremists. One of them later murdered Ali.
-
11
41 AH (661 CE)
Al-Hasan's treaty with Mu'awiyah
●● Different readings
Both accept
After Ali was killed, al-Hasan handed rule to Mu'awiyah by treaty. The Prophet ﷺ had said: "perhaps Allah will make peace through him between two great parties of Muslims" (Sahih al-Bukhari 2704).
Why it matters: Both praise al-Hasan. They differ on whether Mu'awiyah's rule became legitimate as a result.
On the timeline →Sunni reading
A noble act that reunited the ummah in the "Year of Unity". The rightly guided caliphate lasted thirty years and then became kingship (Jami' al-Tirmidhi 2226, hasan; Sunan Abi Dawud 4646). Al-Hasan's six months complete those thirty years.
Sahih al-Bukhari 2704 · Jami' al-Tirmidhi 2226 (hasan) · Sunan Abi Dawud 4646
Shia reading
A forced truce (sulh) by the second Imam to save the lives of the faithful. Mu'awiyah later broke its terms, including the term that he would not name a successor.
· Shaykh Radi Al Yasin, Sulh al-Hasan (modern)
-
12
c. 41-99 AH (661-718 CE)
Ali cursed from the pulpits
●● Different readings
Both accept
Under the Umayyads Ali was cursed from the pulpits. Sahih Muslim records Mu'awiyah asking Sa'd why he would not curse "Abu Turab", and a governor of Madinah ordering Sahl ibn Sa'd to curse him (Sahih Muslim 2404, 2409). Umar ibn Abd al-Aziz stopped the practice.
Why it matters: This experience shaped Shia identity as the party of the persecuted family.
On the timeline →Sunni reading
A grave wrong that Sunni sources themselves record. Sunni Muslims love Ali and count him among the best of the Companions.
Shia reading
Proof of Umayyad hostility to the Prophet's family, and the reason Shia Muslims refuse to treat all Companions as above criticism.
·
-
13
10 Muharram 61 AH (October 680 CE)
Karbala
●●● The divide deepened
Both accept
Al-Husayn refused to pledge allegiance to Yazid. He was killed at Karbala with his family and companions, and his head was taken to Ibn Ziyad, who poked it with a stick (Sahih al-Bukhari 3748; ).
Why it matters: Karbala turned a political party (shi'at Ali) into a religious community with its own memory and rituals.
On the timeline →Sunni reading
A great crime against the Prophet's grandson, who died a martyr. Sunni Muslims fast on Ashura for the Sunnah of Musa's deliverance (Sahih al-Bukhari 2004) and grieve for al-Husayn, but discourage ritual self-harm.
Shia reading
The central event of Shia piety. The third Imam gave his life to save Islam from corruption. It is remembered every year in Muharram through majalis, mourning processions and ziyarah to his shrine. Bloody self-harm (tatbir) is contested within Shia scholarship itself: leading maraji' such as Abu al-Hasan al-Isfahani and Kashif al-Ghita' forbade it, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei declared it unlawful in 1994, and Ayatollah al-Sistani has declined to rule on it, saying only that mourning must not cause serious bodily harm.
· (via ) · · Ali Khamenei, statement of 7 June 1994 (khamenei.ir, "Tatbir is a wrongful and fabricated tradition") · O. Scharbrodt, "Contesting ritual practices in Twelver Shiism: the politics of self-flagellation (tatbir)", British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies (2022), doi:10.1080/13530194.2022.2057279
-
14
61-148 AH (680-765 CE)
From party to doctrine: the Imamate
●●● The divide deepened
Both accept
Ali Zayn al-Abidin, Muhammad al-Baqir and Ja'far al-Sadiq taught in Madinah and kept out of politics. Sunni scholars narrate from them, for example the Hajj hadith of Jabir narrated by Ja'far from his father (Sahih Muslim 1218). The Prophet ﷺ spoke of twelve leaders from Quraysh (Sahih al-Bukhari 7222; Sahih Muslim 1821).
Why it matters: Here leadership became a matter of doctrine and belief, not only of history.
Sunni reading
These men were great scholars of the Prophet's family, but not infallible. Leadership comes through consultation and pledge. The "twelve" are understood as just rulers (Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, Ali, Umar ibn Abd al-Aziz and others).
Sahih Muslim 1218, 1821 · Sahih al-Bukhari 7222 · (commentary on the twelve)
Shia reading
Twelve Imams, each designated by the one before, are protected from error (ma'sum) and are the authoritative interpreters of the religion. The "twelve" hadith refers to them. Ja'far al-Sadiq's teaching became the Ja'fari school of law.
(Kitab al-Hujjah) ·
-
15
122 AH (740 CE)
Zayd ibn Ali's revolt and the word "Rafidah"
●● Different readings
Both accept
Zayd ibn Ali rose against the Umayyads in Kufa and was killed, and his body was crucified ().
Why it matters: Shi'ism itself divided (Zaydi and Imami), and "Rafidi" became a hostile label used ever since.
On the timeline →Sunni reading
Zayd was a respected member of the Prophet's family. Al-Tabari reports that those who left him after he refused to disown Abu Bakr and Umar were called "Rafidah", the rejecters.
(year 122)
Shia reading
Twelvers honour Zayd as a martyr but follow al-Baqir and al-Sadiq as Imams. Zaydis made him an Imam and hold that any learned descendant of Fatimah who rises against injustice may be Imam. Many early Zaydis accepted the caliphate of Abu Bakr and Umar.
(on the Zaydiyyah) ·
-
16
132-247 AH (750-861 CE)
The Abbasids and the Alids
●● Different readings
Both accept
The Abbasid revolution was fought in the name of "the chosen one from the family of Muhammad". Once in power, the Abbasids crushed Alid revolts (al-Nafs al-Zakiyyah, 145 AH), and al-Mutawakkil had al-Husayn's shrine destroyed ().
Why it matters: Sunni and Shia communities each built their own scholarly institutions apart from the other.
On the timeline →Sunni reading
The Abbasid caliphs were the recognised rulers, with many faults. The Sunni schools of law and the great hadith collections took shape under them, often in spite of the state: Malik and Ahmad ibn Hanbal were both flogged.
(years 145, 147, 218, 236)
Shia reading
The Imams were watched, imprisoned and, Shia sources say, poisoned: Musa al-Kazim died in Harun's prison and Ali al-Rida at Tus. The Abbasids betrayed the family they claimed to represent.
·
-
17
260 AH (874 CE) onwards
The Occultation and the Mahdi
●●● The divide deepened
Both accept
Both traditions expect the Mahdi, a descendant of the Prophet ﷺ who will fill the earth with justice (Sunan Abi Dawud 4282-4284, hasan).
Why it matters: Twelver Shi'ism took its final doctrinal form, and religious authority passed to the scholars.
Sunni reading
The Mahdi will be born in the future and has not yet appeared.
Sunan Abi Dawud 4282-4284
Shia reading
The twelfth Imam, Muhammad ibn al-Hasan, was born in 255 AH. He went into a minor occultation in 260 AH, communicating through four deputies, and then a major occultation from 329 AH. He is alive and will return as the Mahdi. In his absence the scholars (marja') guide the community.
·
-
18
3rd-5th centuries AH (9th-11th CE)
Formalisation: separate canons and public rituals
●● Different readings
Both accept
In the 3rd century AH Sunni scholars compiled the Six Books, including Bukhari and Muslim. In the 4th and 5th centuries Shia scholars compiled the Four Books: al-Kafi, Man La Yahduruhu al-Faqih, al-Tahdhib and al-Istibsar. Under the Buyids, public Ashura mourning began in Baghdad in 352 AH, and clashes between Sunni and Shia quarters followed (; ).
Why it matters: The two communities came to have different hadith collections, so they began to disagree about what the evidence even is.
Sunni reading
Hadith are judged by the Sunni science of narrators, which accepts the Companions as a body as trustworthy.
(year 352) ·
Shia reading
Hadith come through the Imams of Ahl al-Bayt, and narrators are judged by Shia rijal works ().
·
-
19
297-567 AH (909-1171 CE)
The Fatimid (Isma'ili) caliphate
●● Different readings
Both accept
An Isma'ili Shia dynasty ruled North Africa and Egypt, founded Cairo and al-Azhar, and rivalled the Abbasids. Salah al-Din ended it in 1171 ().
Why it matters: The rivalry became a contest between states, not only between scholars.
On the timeline →Sunni reading
A rival and illegitimate caliphate. Its end restored the Abbasid khutbah in Egypt, and al-Azhar became a Sunni institution.
Shia reading
Twelvers do not recognise the Isma'ili Imams after Ja'far al-Sadiq, though Isma'ilis do. The Fatimids show that Shi'ism is not a single body.
-
20
1501 CE onwards
The Safavids and the Ottomans
●●● The divide deepened
Both accept
Shah Isma'il I made Twelver Shi'ism the state religion of Iran in 1501, often by force, and imported Shia scholars from Jabal Amil. Wars with the Sunni Ottomans followed, starting with Chaldiran in 1514 ().
Why it matters: The divide became a border between empires, and the map of Sunni and Shia lands we know today took shape.
On the timeline →Sunni reading
The forced conversion of a largely Sunni Iran, and the public ritual cursing of the first caliphs (tabarra), deeply hurt Sunni Muslims. The Ottomans treated the Safavids as an enemy state.
·
Shia reading
For the first time a major state made Twelver Shi'ism its religion and protected it, and the great seminaries of Isfahan grew. Many Shia scholars today condemn insulting the Companions and the Prophet's wives (for example Ayatollah Khamenei's 2010 fatwa).
· Fatwa of Ali Khamenei on insulting the Mothers of the Believers (2010)
-
21
20th-21st centuries
Today: conflict and bridges
● Shared ground
Both accept
Sectarian violence in recent decades, in Iraq, Syria and Pakistan, has killed many thousands. There have also been efforts to bring the two together: al-Azhar's 1959 fatwa by Shaykh Mahmud Shaltut allowed worship according to the Ja'fari school, and the (2004-2005) was signed by Sunni and Shia scholars and recognised each other's schools of law as Muslim.
Why it matters: The method this site follows applies here: go back to the Qur'an and authentic sources, avoid sectarian labels, and judge actions rather than whole communities.
On the timeline →Sunni reading
The mainstream Sunni position (al-Azhar, the ) is that Shia Muslims are Muslims and must not be declared disbelievers. Some groups reject this.
(ammanmessage.com), 2005 · Fatwa of Mahmud Shaltut, al-Azhar (1959)
Shia reading
Leading marja' have signed the Amman Message and forbidden insulting what Sunnis hold sacred. Some groups still reject this too.
(ammanmessage.com), 2005
Reading this page fairly
Each column states what mainstream scholars of that tradition hold, in their own terms and from their own books. Strong words used by some writers on either side are not repeated here. Where the shared hadith collections (sunnah.com) record something, it appears under “Both accept”. Where a report is weak or late, it is labelled.
Both traditions honour the Prophet’s family. Both regard the killing of al-Husayn at Karbala as a crime. In 2005 the Amman Message, signed by scholars of both, affirmed that followers of the Sunni schools and the Ja‘fari (Twelver Shia) school are Muslims. Items that could not be traced to a verifiable source were left out and are listed for checking.